Friday, April 30, 2010

Poland After The Second World War

Post-war Poland was a drastically different country from the one it was before the war. A new political authority, economic instability, and lack of religious diversity marked the beginning of a new Poland. The new politically authority of Poland was the Soviet Union. Before the war, Poland had been independent and self sufficient. After the war, the Western leaders forced Poland to accept the conditions of Stalin. This is a matter of continuing resentment for some Poles even today. Some view it as a "betrayalof Poland by the Western allies because they allowed Poland to fall entirely into the Soviet sphere of influence. Poland was now under Soviet military control who sought to turn Poland into a Communist country. Throughout the history of this Poland, there had been large variety religious populations. However, due to the Holocaust and the attempted annihilation of Jewish and other discriminated religions, approximately 97% of the remaining population after the war belonged to the Roman Catholic Church. Not only did the war damage the diversity of religion in Poland, it damaged the economy. Poland's urban centers were devastated as a result of war. Many people were left homeless, children orphaned, infrastructures were destroyed, and the rate of illness and infection increased. Prices were high, wages were low, and everyday supplies were difficult to get. There was also a growing gap between the rich and poor. Throughout Poland, there was much displeasure with the authorities who were unable to ease the economic situation. In 1945 The Soviet Union pushed the Communist party into control and the country was renamed "People's Republic of Poland." The rise of the Communist Party did not result out of public vote or appeal with the Communist Party. Because of this, many Poles were uneasy with this new political authority. In September 1988 a secret meeting was held to discuss the need to radically alter the shape of the Polish government and society. Throughout time, events in Poland, like the one in this video, led to the fall of the entire Communist party. Poland became the first Warsaw Pact state country to break free of Soviet domination and the first new non-Communist government in Eastern Europe.



Looking through the history of Poland, you can see many arguments that are still debated even today. After the war, Poland became an increasingly unwelcome place for Jews. Because the number of Jews, as well as populations of non-Polish ethnic groups, had diminished so much in Poland, Catholicism and Polish identity became more tightly intertwined and became important to Polish nationalism. Though Jews had been a part of Polish history for centuries, they did not meet the ideal nationalist standards and therefore they faced anti-Jewish sentiment in the form of encouraged emigration. In the late 1940s, large waves of Jewish people emigrated out of Poland until the Jewish population almost ceased to exist and left Poland with basically only one religion. It is easy to argue whether or not the country’s unanimous religion was really a good thing for Poland. Most people would think that a country with the same religion would be ideal and they would come together so powerfully, and this is true. However I don’t believe that that was a good thing in the case of Poland. That is because the Soviet Union used the fact that the majority followed the Catholic Church to secretly manipulate Poland. Until 1947, the Catholic Church was free from censorship and repression. Stalin found this to be a way to turn Poland to communism like he had originally planned. The Soviet Union told the church that in order to maintain its freedom, the Church had to cooperate with the Communist Party on some levels. The Communist Party, desiring to use the Church as a means of influence, often asked that it preside over political funerals and use its sermons for political manipulation. This indicated to those attending that the Church was in agreement with Communist Party. Another debatable argument is whether or not Stalin’s idea of communism for Poland was such a terrible thing. The people may have not voted the communist party into position, but the power the Party meant opportunities for individuals who were looking for jobs in the damaged economy and would help those attempting to rebuild lives and secure futures. I believe that Stalin’s idea was unnecessary and that he shouldn’t have been given control of Poland in the first place. I believe that Poland was betrayed by the Western leaders because they deserved to have control of their own government since they fought Germany just as all the other allies did. Although the communist party was helping the economy, I think Poland could have rebuilt them selves after the war and that is why they broke away from the Soviet Union to form and independent country again.







7 comments:

  1. I do not agree with the idea of the allies defending Poland against the Soviet Union because did you consider that the allies did not want to start another world war and also, the Soviet Union helped the allies defeat Germany.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It is extremely unfortunate that the Allies forced Poland to bend to the will of the Soviet Union. Couldn't they see the damage that it would do to Poland. I don't know why someone would disagree with the Allies defending Poland but it is very disturbing that the Allies treated Poland as something that they could trade to the Soviet Union to protect their interests.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I thought your article was very interesting and I liked it a lot. However, what were some examples of damaged Poland religion at this time?

    ReplyDelete
  4. This may sound harsh...but the Soviet Union should have just expanded their territory onto Poland's land. Instead of redesigning Poland's government it would have been easier to hand them a Russian flag and force them to obey Stalin. It's not like they would fight back...it's Poland. When have they ever fought back?

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think that it could have helped Poland if Stalin had them use a form of communism, but it can only be temporary and that was not how he was intending to use it.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think that having one big religion in a country is not the best thing to have. For example before the Soviet Union took over Poland had man different religions and people could decided what they wanted to believe. After the Soviet Union invaded with communism Poland lost all there different religions and it just turned into one main one. I think that it is good for country's to have many different religions in them because it makes the country's more diverse.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I find it so funny how most religions aim to promote peace and unity under their god(s) and yet there is so much hatred towards other people that settles around religion. Once you think about it, politics and religion are the root of all evil. Although it sounds ironic, it is true once you think about it. There were so many wars and deaths which occurred over religion and politics. The two are supposed to be separate, or at least should be (such as in America) and yet in instances such as those with the Soviet Union and Poland, the Church is using Politics and vice versa. I don't exactly think that's the type of "religion" God intended.

    ReplyDelete